Blues is different than any other type of music. In blues, notes aren't played at the pitch you would expect. Also, blues has this distinctive solid but plaintive sound. This sound resonates from the use of a minor-based scale over the top of a major-based chord. Pecola's life worked in this way. Her story in the book is solid from the beginning. You know what is going to happen to her and that the book tells how it will happen. It is also very plaintive. No one is happy when thinking about the troubles that Pecola had to go through. Her story is a sad and mournful one that isn't hidden but is set up to where you know her life is crummy. Her miserable life comes from people trying to do things that they shouldn't be. Just as these minor-based scales are put on major-based chords, people in her life, which in a usual situation, are put in things that they normally shouldn't be. Like her father for example. Dad's don't normally rape their daughters when they see them washing dishes and look miserable. They don't think about harming her in a gentle way. They don't think he way that Pecola's dad did in a normal situation. Yet, because of what her father did that isn't normal, it created this new misery in her life.
What is conflicting is the part about notes played at the pitch you wouldn't expect. In Pecola's situation, you would expect a little girl that presumes she is ugly to want blue eyes to fit in and be beautiful. She is young and thinks that by having this thing that is unimaginable would cause her problems to be fixed. But, Pecola's life is full of parts that aren't expected. I know that I was surprised by all that happened in this book to her. She goes through so much that you wouldn't expect a little girl to go through. The bullying and teasing are expected since everyone thought she was ugly but a boy tricking her into his house and her harming a cat. That is unexpected. Her life isn't predictable at all. Yes, we know she will be raped and the baby will die. But the stuff that leads up to that is so unexpected.
This could very much contradict with the statement said before that her life is solid. If it's solid then you would know what to expect, but you don't. What is to happen to her is solid but her life getting here isn't really so. So in a way, Cat Moses is right. Pecola's life resembles a blues song in how the distinct sounds are made in a blues song and the plaintive, unexpected nature of it.
